Well, of the trio that comprises the chorus of that famous song, now only Willie Mays remains on this earth, what with the recent passing of Duke Snider.
Obviously, comparing those three star outfielders was a buzzy topic in the 1950s, and this article really nails why it was such a hot topic:
The reason, of course, was that there was no “wrong answer”! Willie, Mickey Mantle, and the Duke all put together monster seasons. If you liked all-around play, Mays was your man. If you preferred the dramatic homers, obviously you’d root for the Mick. If you liked the solid underdog who just keeps his mouth shut and still puts up great numbers, than the Duke was for you.
About the closest I’ve ever come to this sort of “quandary” was in the late 1990s with these three guys:
Nomar Garciaparra, Derek Jeter, and A-Rod dominated SS in the American League for quite a few seasons. I was always partially to “Nomah”, but you couldn’t go wrong with any of them.